The Advocates – Video: Should Your State Restore the Death Penalty?

by

Series: The Advocates

Episode: 313

Original Link: https://americanarchive.org/catalog/cpb-aacip-15-2r3nv9997h

Video Embed:

Episode Summary:

This episode of The Advocates debated whether states should restore the death penalty in light of the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision deeming existing statutes unconstitutional for being applied in a “wantonly and freakishly” arbitrary manner. Advocate William Rusher and his witnesses—including Florida Attorney General Robert Shevin and philosopher Rev. Bruce Williams—argued in favor of restoration, contending that the death penalty serves retributive justice, demonstrates the seriousness with which society regards murder, and deters especially heinous crimes like premeditated murder or the killing of police or prison guards by those already serving life sentences. They maintained that with properly designed legislation—such as mandatory sentences for well-defined crimes—the penalty could be applied uniformly and justly, satisfying the Court’s objections.

Opposing restoration, Harvard law professor Alan Dershowitz and his witnesses—including Pennsylvania Attorney General Shane Creamer and psychiatrist Dr. Louis West—argued that the death penalty is both unnecessary and fundamentally flawed. They cited authoritative studies showing no deterrent effect on murder rates, pointed to states with the highest execution rates also having the most murders, and highlighted the racial and socioeconomic disparities in its application. Opponents contended that abolishing the death penalty has not led to increased crime and that life imprisonment fully protects society without risking wrongful execution, exacerbating social inequality, or diverting resources away from needed criminal justice reforms.

The debate ultimately contrasted philosophical arguments about retribution and moral principle with empirical evidence and concerns about fairness and error. The proponents insisted society must uphold its deepest values with ultimate penalties for the most grievous crimes; the opponents responded that compassion, the prevention of irreversible mistakes, and a more just criminal system demand abolition. The audience and viewers were invited to vote and share their views in what was portrayed as a crucial, highly contested issue facing every state.

Author

  • The William A. Rusher Centennial Project aims to produce substantive intellectual media that, rooted in Mr. Rusher’s work, pushes today’s conservative movement to adopt a more coherent philosophy, a stronger coalition, and a more effective set of political and legal strategies. In short, the Project aims, as Mr. Rusher aimed, to get more votes for conservatism. And in so doing, it aims to inspire respect and enthusiasm the way Mr. Rusher did, while fighting effectively, confidently, and cheerfully for the conservative views he articulated. Those views, rooted in Locke and Burke, and founded in the Declaration of Independence, are not necessarily those views often misidentified today as “conservative.” The Project seeks to advance and to adapt Mr. Rusher’s views -- in line with his legacy -- so that they have broad resonance and appeal in the current political environment.

    View all posts

Recent Articles

Quotes About William Rusher

“Nobody, but nobody, was more at the heart of this. Rusher’s fingerprints were everywhere—and not just involved, but you get a feeling that he was pulling an awful lot of the strings.” — Richard Viguerie, referring to Rusher’s role in the conservative movement over...

The Quotable Bill Rusher Part 2: From His Books

Special Counsel (1968) “… a steady diet of political infighting tends to coarsen, and ultimately to cheapen, most participants. They approach politics as reasonably honorable citizens, and by imperceptible degrees it sucks them into its vortex. The plainly right...

The Quotable Bill Rusher

from If Not Us, Who? William Rusher, National Review, and the Conservative Movement “Politicians are the grease on which society’s wheels turn. And they can’t be better, most of the time, than a sort of low competence and honor.”—from an interview for Rusher’s...

Rusher at 100: Realism for the 21st Century

(June 23, 2023—revised December 21, 2023) William Rusher, a dynamic force on the American right who passed away in 2011 after decades as comrade and mentor to many conservatives, was born a full century ago on July 19, 1923. His centenary comes at a hard time for...

Book Presentation: “If Not Us, Who?” by David B. Frisk

Click to watch the presentation of "If Not Us, Who?" by David Frisk to the Heritage Foundation in Washington DC on C-SPAN. David Frisk's book, If Not Us, Who?: William Rusher, 'National Review,' and the Conservative Movement, offers a comprehensive exploration of the...

Bill’s Biography

William Rusher was an influential political strategist, commentator, and debater at the heart of the conservative movement in the second half of the twentieth century, a movement whose ascent he documented in his 1984 book The Rise of the Right -- one of many examples...

More Resources

Quotes About William Rusher

“Nobody, but nobody, was more at the heart of this. Rusher’s fingerprints were everywhere—and not just involved, but you get a feeling that he was pulling an awful lot of the strings.” — Richard Viguerie, referring to Rusher’s role in the conservative movement over...

The Quotable Bill Rusher Part 2: From His Books

Special Counsel (1968) “… a steady diet of political infighting tends to coarsen, and ultimately to cheapen, most participants. They approach politics as reasonably honorable citizens, and by imperceptible degrees it sucks them into its vortex. The plainly right...

The Quotable Bill Rusher

from If Not Us, Who? William Rusher, National Review, and the Conservative Movement “Politicians are the grease on which society’s wheels turn. And they can’t be better, most of the time, than a sort of low competence and honor.”—from an interview for Rusher’s...

“If Not Us, Who?”

If Not Us, Who? takes you on a journey into the life of William Rusher, a key player in shaping the modern conservative movement. Known for his long stint as the publisher of National Review, Rusher wasn't just a publisher—he was a crucial strategist and thinker in...

Contact Us